Question:
What sort of punishment does this man desirve?
2007-05-31 13:29:43 UTC
Man described as a top spammer arrested

By GENE JOHNSON, AP Legal Affairs WriterThu May 31, 8:02 AM ET

A 27-year-old man described as one of the world's most prolific spammers was arrested Wednesday, and federal authorities said computer users across the Web could notice a decrease in the amount of junk e-mail.

Robert Alan Soloway is accused of using networks of compromised "zombie" computers to send out millions upon millions of spam e-mails.

"He's one of the top 10 spammers in the world," said Tim Cranton, a Microsoft Corp. lawyer who is senior director of the company's Worldwide Internet Safety Programs. "He's a huge problem for our customers. This is a very good day."

A federal grand jury last week returned a 35-count indictment against Soloway charging him with mail fraud, wire fraud, e-mail fraud, aggravated identity theft and money laundering.

Soloway pleaded not guilty Wednesday afternoon to all charges after a judge determined that — even with four bank accounts seized by the government — he was sufficiently well off to pay for his own lawyer.

He has been living in a ritzy apartment and drives an expensive Mercedes convertible, said prosecutor Kathryn Warma. Prosecutors are seeking to have him forfeit $773,000 they say he made from his business, Newport Internet Marketing Corp.

A public defender who represented him for Wednesday's hearing declined to comment.

Prosecutors say Soloway used computers infected with malicious code to send out millions of junk e-mails since 2003. The computers are called "zombies" because owners typically have no idea their machines have been infected.

He continued his activities even after Microsoft won a $7 million civil judgment against him in 2005 and the operator of a small Internet service provider in Oklahoma won a $10 million judgment, prosecutors said.

U.S. Attorney Jeff Sullivan said Wednesday that the case is the first in the country in which federal prosecutors have used identity theft statutes to prosecute a spammer for taking over someone else's Internet domain name. Soloway could face decades in prison, though prosecutors said they have not calculated what guideline sentencing range he might face.

The investigation began when the authorities began receiving hundreds of complaints about Soloway, who had been featured on a list of known spammers kept by The Spamhaus Project, an international anti-spam organization.

The Santa Barbara County, Calif., Department of Social Services said it was spending $1,000 a week to fight the spam it was receiving, and other businesses and individuals complained of having their reputations damaged when it appeared spam was originating from their computers.

"This is not just a nuisance. This is way beyond a nuisance," Warma said.

Soloway used the networks of compromised computers to send out unsolicited bulk e-mails urging people to use his Internet marketing company to advertise their products, authorities said.

People who clicked on a link in the e-mail were directed to his Web site. There, Soloway advertised his ability to send out as many as 20 million e-mail advertisements over 15 days for $495, the indictment said.

The Spamhaus Project rejoiced at his arrest.

"Soloway has been a long-term nuisance on the Internet — both in terms of the spam he sent, and the people he duped to use his spam service," organizers wrote on Spamhaus.org.

Soloway remained in federal detention pending a hearing Monday.
22 answers:
?
2007-05-31 13:46:11 UTC
He should be forced to read...aloud...all the Q&A in Y!A Politics.
markus
2007-05-31 13:49:47 UTC
seriously 15-20 years with a big fine just for this fact from the story



"He continued his activities even after Microsoft won a $7 million civil judgment against him in 2005 and the operator of a small Internet service provider in Oklahoma won a $10 million judgment, prosecutors said"



After that a 20 year probation which he can't have, use, or be around a computer.
Chredon
2007-05-31 13:53:54 UTC
I think he should be force-fed Viagra and Cialis.



Any medical needs he has for the rest of his life should be serviced by an on-line pharmacy out of Nigeria.



He should be required to act as an agent for Mr. Obeese Mumgatwa, who wants to transfer $250,000 to the USA through one of his savings accounts.



He should have to invest all of his money in a hot new stock that certain to grow ten times in value over the next six weeks.



He should be weighed down with $15 Rolex watches.



He should spend his evenings answering messages from hot college students who want to meet you.



He should be forced to marry a faithful Russian beauty contest winner who wants to move to the United States.



He should be allowed to send in the required information to get his winnings from 20 international lotteries that he never entered.



He should have to update his information for Paypal, eBay, and every bank that does business in the continental United States, whether he has an account there or not.



And finally, he should be forced to upgrade his computer with this direct-from-Microsoft security update that he received through his E-mail.
2007-05-31 13:42:13 UTC
In my PERSONAL opinion? I think he should have to sit in a room and ONE BY ONE answer to the people he's screwed.I think these folks that do this and also the ones that create 'worms' and viruses or whatever really get some kind of sick joy out of it. I use the internet for information and entertainment. It's my playground. I'm glad this jack *** has been kicked off my playground!

Another idea for punishment.....Maybe stick his butt on a chain gang with NO internet access.
tehabwa
2007-05-31 20:18:05 UTC
A host of people should be with him every single moment of his life interrupting everything he does, every second of every day for 25 years.



The interruptions should require some act on his part to continue what he's doing, which he can continue for no more than 10 seconds at a time, when he's again interrupted and prevented from continuing.
united9198
2007-05-31 13:35:11 UTC
I would force him to take VY**A6RA and get his P•nis enlarged. Then I would make him refinance his home with a spammer and buy some stocks from one of the pump and dump spammers that send you those cute pink e-mails.
Princess of the Realm
2007-05-31 13:52:43 UTC
Life in prison, he should sent out an email to everyone he spammed and apologize, he should never be allowed to use computers or electricity again
2007-05-31 13:35:10 UTC
He deserves to spend a long-time thinking of the damage he has caused. I would suggest they give him an extended prison sentence for his blatant disregard for others and lack of respect of other people's property.
2016-04-01 11:35:15 UTC
firstly, punishment- i would have him walk around a cobblestone street barefoot till' his feet are cut then bleeding, then go to a monestary and whip himself. secondly, prayer-i do not believe in god but i am sad of what this world has come to. thirdly, crime- i do not wish to be disrespectful, but this man is by far not the worst. the only thing that seperates him is that he was seen and reported.
infobrokernate
2007-05-31 13:33:26 UTC
He deserves to have a phone in his cell ringing 24-7 with salesmen calling on vinyl siding, credit card offers, and printer cartridges.
2007-05-31 13:38:47 UTC
Just for future reference, it would have been easier to post a link. Well, he should have a fair trial and then be convicted and sentenced to the longest term possible.
genmalia
2007-05-31 13:41:56 UTC
Payment of fines, prison time, and seizure of equipment to help track online pedofiles and predators.
2007-05-31 13:40:19 UTC
He should be placed in solitary confinement until he copies each and every email he was responsible for in long hand. Twice.
Jenny
2007-05-31 13:55:10 UTC
The same as they give to virus creators.
pattypat999
2007-05-31 13:54:58 UTC
He should be sentenced to all of the above. I was one that was a victim of this.
2007-05-31 13:35:43 UTC
He has to listen to tapes of every speech George W. Bush has ever given. Keep him in jail and watching them until he apologizes or until Bush's Farewell Address, whichever comes first. He'll probably crack before "Mission Accomplished."
Sageandscholar
2007-05-31 21:54:59 UTC
Great - we got him! Can we try to catch Bin Laden now?
2007-05-31 13:33:22 UTC
He should be put on display in a stockade in front of Microsoft headquarters for all to see and do what they please. Then, off to jail. Throw away the key.
Brand X
2007-05-31 13:37:07 UTC
He should have to write "I will not spam" tens of billions of times.
2007-05-31 13:34:24 UTC
I say feed him with SPAM (the food) for the rest of his life.
2007-05-31 13:34:01 UTC
so cool we hate spam

5 yrs or a huge fine!!!!!!!!!!
Chunky & Lumpy
2007-05-31 13:45:17 UTC
give him death


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...