Question:
What are some pros and cons of NBN fibre-to-the-home scheme?
Yahoo!7 Australia Answers Team
2013-09-22 18:18:22 UTC
The entire NBN Co board has reportedly submitted their resignations to Communications Minister Malcolm Turnbull, over concerns the Abbott government will not deliver the project.

In the spirit of some objective debate, we want to know what are some advantages and disadvantages of fibre-to-the-home scheme?
Eighteen answers:
?
2013-09-22 18:31:19 UTC
copper is outdated

telstra are a rip off company
?
2013-09-26 03:02:52 UTC
http://www.change.org/en-AU/petitions/the-liberal-party-of-australia-reconsider-your-plan-for-a-fttn-nbn-in-favour-of-a-superior-ftth-nbn



The above is a petition to Malcolm Turnbull that basically explains all the cons of what's supposedly happening. It might give you some insight as to why people are resigning.

Basically, we'll be using a system that's already been updated in the rest of the world. Why not just fast forward to what everyone else is moving on to.



The copper is weak and will have to be re-installed in a few years anyway. No privacy + more control over what we do and how we use the internet from the government.

Central city areas will have fast internet, but the further you go out into the country the slower the internet, we will all be paying the same amount though.
steve c
2013-09-24 15:47:13 UTC
Personally I find this whole debate nothing short of stunning

Shortly after Labor came out with the whole NBN idea Australia was visited by a gentleman by the name of Carlos Slim Who at that time was the worlds richest man (now second) Who made his fortune in telecommunications. Mr Slim was of the opinion that Labors NBN was not the right way for Australia to go. Not surprisingly The Government of the day felt that they knew better than the most successful person in the field and ignored him.

What astounds me however is that few people in our media drip feed country seem to ask why would the world most successful telecommunications Mogul find fault in the proposed NBN and ask for his opinion on a better system?



Putting aside the fact that we think we should have the best whether we need it or not why why why do so many people think its so important to have fiber to your house for mind blowing speeds when your router will determine the end usage speed anyway.



Sorry if im stretching here but outside of work in the industry don't 90% of us use wireless anyway???

Everyone I know use smart phones now , im old fashioned these days still using wireless lap top so in an honest real world who needs the super fast speeds on offer at a crazy price when we all use wireless anyway



Hospitals and industry will get fiber anyway the rest of us don't need it for any other reason but ego
?
2016-03-11 01:02:15 UTC
I understand about the whole no Islamic school thing - that can be a problem. But, I wouldn't home school them. Knowing you, I have faith that your child (or even a relative's child) could go to a public school and still have firm beliefs and not do anything that would compromise that. Public school provides a good chance of learning communication skills and making new friends. Home schooling would be difficult in terms of those things - even though the child would always be comfortable at home, sometimes it's better to get them out of their shells. You can also opt for the child to not attend such festivals :) It's part of your rights as a parent. For example, I remember watching a documentary where a young girl was the only Muslim in her school in New Zealand, but arrangements were just easily made for her - her mum came on the school camp and she didn't go to the discos, as well as her having time for prayer each day. I think many public schools are really welcoming to different religious beliefs, so you wouldn't have many problems about that. I think studying faiths is extremely important for children as well - while they may be wrong, it does provide them with understanding and acceptance of other people's personal religions. I also think it could strengthen their own faith. How about asking some sisters near you how they have done it? Maybe they have some personal recommendations about schools? <3
Maya
2015-01-14 19:08:35 UTC
Fibre to the Premises (FTTP) is a telecommunication network that uses optical fibre cables to connect homes and businesses to a high speed network that can be used to provide high speed broadband and phone services.



FTTP involves laying optical fibre from a central location (switch) to a termination point (the home or business). The technology is capable of transmitting data at speeds of up to 100Mbps (5x faster than ADSL2+).



NBN have plans to be able to offer new telephone technology in NBN Fibre and NBN Wireless areas that will replace fixed (copper) phone lines in the years to come.
?
2013-09-23 00:25:05 UTC
To start youve misrepresented the news



the entire board has not submitted their resignations



to the question, its a moot point



LNP went to the election promising an inferior ultimately more expensive scheme, so thats whats they will do



the pros of FTTP (fibre to the premises is the correct term) are very simply that the future of our entire economy relies on quality internet, its faster, its more reliable and it doesnt rely on outdated degrading existing technology



the cons are as good as nil except for the investment required which in any event is spread over decades and offset by commercial involvement



bring on a benevolent dictatorship rather then this democracy manned by idiots
2013-09-23 04:47:34 UTC
Cons:

1. Complete visibility to EVERYTHING you do online. Privacy will be a thing of the past

2. mandatory reporting to various government departments of everything you do online

3. Increased sharing of information with federal and international agencies

4. Increased tel$tra monopoly = drastically reduced service level. Telstra now will give you the worst service they can that you will let them give you. Once NBN comes in you will get less service, higher costs, less stability and nothing in return

5. The NBN is not going to fix the archaic and draconian policies of the tel$tra monopoly.

6. The TIO will have even less power than they do now to advocate on your behalf.

7. More controls on what you can do. Your freedom of choice will diminish quickly over time. You won't be able to choose which products you buy, which websites you visit and so on.

8. Drastically increased level of "targeted advertising" (side effect really), which is really nothing more that malware.

9. Increased taxes to pay for it.





Pro's

1. Occasionally faster internet
2016-04-05 08:56:09 UTC
For the best answers, search on this site https://shorturl.im/aygrx



Dear, Pe be upon you. In the Name of Allah The Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. There things to be consider. 1. The Official Education System of the Country 2. Qualifying Education that recognize by own country and other countries. 3. The FAITH towards the religion of Islam. 1. Country's Education System. Maybe your Country Education Laws says that Education is Compulsory. Therefore you are liable to be charge in Court. If not compulsory, the children shall be uneducated according to the country's Education System. 2. Recognition of Education in the country and oversea. The country will not be able to grade a person in any status. To apply job with the government, firm or private sector. No Future study in local and overseas University. 3. The FAITH toward the Religion. These are a MUST. Of course there are time to educate the children at home. It's normal to every Islamic parent in the world teaching their children at home or sending them to the Islamic Centre apart from compulsory education in any country. It's part of the parent's duty towards the children to educate the children them self or through grouping. This must start at the earliest. Some started at the age of 3 years before reaching the normal age of schooling. My opinion it's a must to every parent to educate children minimum at the age of 4 years to begin the Islamic study at home, Islamic Center or anywhere. These are fundamental needs. No College or High School for Children age 13 years start or begin with from A or Alif (begining) in teaching of Islamic religion or Islamic Study. You must be able to recognize Alphabet A-Z, Numbers 0-9 (or 1-10, tenth digit, hundred digits, thousand digits and so on) and from Alif to Hamzah. Wabillahhitaufiq Walhidayah Wassalamu'alaikum Warahmatullahhi Wabarakatuh.
Riley
2013-09-22 20:15:53 UTC
The pros and cons are no different than choosing buying a new car paying a little more or buying a cheap old second hand one that will only last a few years. It seems Mr I'll fix the infrastructure Abbott, isn't keeping to his word with wanting to keep the old copper wire that we currently have. Than fully completing the new optic fiber system the NBN has been laying down under ground, which will last for over 60 plus years and will fully compatible with all the undersea optic fiber system that connects to all other global countries.



Compared to current copper wire that has half life that oxidizes if its under ground. That's while it's all on power poles and you have to turn all your computer and other equipment during a lightning storm, to avoid a power surge or if some one hits a power pole, your Foxtel, Austar, Optus TV, and all IPS channels on Fetch TV, Telstra T-Box, PlayStation etc and the net go down, until they fix the cables. 'Which isn't good enough in 2013, especially how much we actually pay for these services in Australia'. Compared to other country's in the world which are a under a third of the price what we all pay. Yet as consumers we still have a yesteryear system, and are sharing all of our phone, cable television and internet provider systems with Telstra and Big Pond services.



Who charges all of the major phone and internet provider company's a fee which all flows onto us and our bills, that's we pay through the teeth. If Mr I'll fix the infrastructure Abbott, has his way keeping the copper wire system we will remain being many years behind in broadband technology with a slow internet speeds and over paying for this lemon. Even Romania and Korea has faster broadband speed than we do as well their internet, cable television, and phone services are a third of the price we pay.



If it wasn't for all of these political argument causing hold ups, it would have all been fully rolled out now. Our taxes have 'already' paid for this, the more they delay and argue it's costing billions more of our tax dollars than it was originally set at. They should finish this NBN project ASAP than just playing politics and putting it on hold which will cost more in the future to fully bring it up to global standard. This is just showing not even three weeks after the election that we going to have three more years of 'nothing' getting done. Mr I'll fix the infrastructure Abbott, needs to realise that's the only reason why was voted in. He promised no more of these games and would finally get things done. I and millions of other Australians are angered seeing our tax dollars that have already been spent, being wasted on all these half finished projects.



Addition..The NBN project was to make it more affordable and accessible for even granny to get on line. It seems that still had the liberal government for the last few year we would still of had analog television with only five channels than Freeview digital SD HD channels which the liberal Howard government held back too. Lets hope the full switch over is still on December 13th 2013, not four years from now.
Alex Martin
2015-01-14 19:10:47 UTC
Well now the fttn is being built by Telstra for $43b. And for the same money, we could have had world class fibre to the home.
Paul M
2013-09-26 00:28:13 UTC
pros - fiber optic is indeed quick & the infrastructure does need upgrading .



cons . firstly it is over hyped , it is not coming to isolated country areas where it is really needed (ADSL 2 in the city is really quiet quick where satellite in the country is about dial up speed most times)



so as usual - the only real winners will be city dwellers
Fake Genius
2013-09-22 21:52:41 UTC
give that technology to universities, institutions and main businesses - I.E. major cities. those live along the connections can have it. the rest copper wire. no problem. ordinary people wouldn't have to need it yet.

imo
2013-09-23 08:29:12 UTC
PROS : Keeps incompetent people in a job

CONS : Costs the community shitloads for a product that is a failure from day one and well after it has been sunk we will still be paying for it.
2013-09-25 05:21:00 UTC
Pro: we won't be so far behind the rest of the world.



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jmD-uFgcvbU
AVG CON
2013-09-22 18:46:20 UTC
I don't have a clue what you are talking about. But I'm just a self absorbed American.



You live near the coast or the outback?
?
2013-09-22 18:37:42 UTC
Fiber be fast.
?
2013-09-25 19:35:56 UTC
sympathy
?
2013-09-22 18:27:50 UTC
ive never seen staffs before hello from virginia


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...