Question:
Free market economy really guarantees political & economic freedom or it just gives a illusion of freedom?
?
2013-04-12 05:43:24 UTC
Capitalism can survive in a liberal democracy(by sucking and slowly killing its democratic life.Eg Europe and USA) setup but it can also ally itself in a dictatorial country like China and even survive in monarchist- feudalist nations like Saudi Arabia,Bahrain and Qatar ..and this list goes on...The so called entrepreneurship spirit does not requires democracy necessarily to progress.Business people require governments which will favor their personal growth and make laws conducive for doing profitable business.The role of the government primarily in a market based economy has been to ensure profitability of firms rather than promoting human rights ,justice and freedom.When advocates of free market talk about freedom they talk about political and economic independence of business (especially large ones) from any societal or constitutional constraints and not about political and economic freedom of common wage earners and unemployed people.These free market pundits are against worker's unions fundamental right to organize -----right to oppose social-economic injustice and political organization is a basic human right in democratic system .Even many times they are against consumer protection advocacy.A large group among these free market advocates are even claiming that human induced climate change(scientifically proven fact) is a myth because the laws and regulations enacted to save climate and planet will effect the profitability of firms. So this raises an important point is free market economy really guarantees political ,economic and social freedom or it just gives a illusion of freedom and drains away democratic rights of citizens?
Eight answers:
2013-04-12 05:48:47 UTC
Don't look behind the curtain.....damn, I told you not to look....
draciron
2013-04-12 06:32:59 UTC
You are correct in surmising that Free market capitalism is completely independent of of government. Marxists tend to confuse this because of the unholy welding of an economic system into a form of government that is Socialism. Free market economies when they have existed have brought about great improvements in standards of living, knowledge, innovation, science, medicine and tended to bring about a much happier populace. These economies have existed under many forms of government but there are three critical elements to make a free market work. Capitalism is not itself a free market. A free market capitalist economic system is just one of several forms of capitalism.



To establish a free market these conditions must exist and be maintained.

1. Control of monopolies to prevent collusion, unfair trade practices and intervention.

2. Limited government involvement in the economy.

3. Low levels of corruption.

4. Sufficient capital in the hands of upper middle class and wealthy to create new businesses and invest in existing businesses.

5. Lessened or total lack of class system restraints or some sort of loop holes that allow common people to rise up as ability and luck allow.

6. Sufficient trade partners or an economically sustainable internal customer base.



Socialist Democracies cannot provide any of these conditions. Having a strong central government which is necessary for a Socialist anything means there will be high levels of corruption which leads to Corporatism. This kills the free market aspect. Capital is sucked up into taxation leaving only the very wealthy able to invest and sustain business. Socialism creates class systems and becomes a barrier to upward or downward mobility of it's people. Staticism is the very goal of Socialism so by design it is meant to keep people in their place. The lack of internal capital makes it very difficult for an internal market and only by temporary measures can a Socialist nation like China create favorable trade conditions. The gross inefficiency however of the government will eventually kill these conditions.



As such a Socialist nation is incapable of sustaining a free market economic system. The very reason man of our protections are so closely guarded in the US is to prevent the very things Corporatism and Socialism bring to a nation. A free press is supposed to guard against corruption but in the US today the media is OWNED by the very groups which control our government and influence our political parties. The use of blackmail advertising has created a situation where the press has repeatedly been silenced by corporate and special interests so as to abet corruption and wrong doing.



I'll disagree with you on climate change. It's not carbon it's deforestation and the so called efforts to battle climate change do far more harm to the environment than the problems they are meant to solve. Most of it like carbon credits is nothing but a giant get rich scheme and political means to punish groups and industries which support right wing groups and agendas. Punitive actions against the "wealthy" by the wealthy for the wealthy. It is a battle for dollars not the environment. I am a former member of many environmental groups but left in disgust over the politicization of the movement and the way it has become nothing but an arm of the DNC. The environment is far too important to make a political play toy. The climate change movement has done exactly that. Made a mockery of every principle for which environmentalism was supposed to stand for.



Unions served a vital role in the past, today however many are nothing but an arm of the DNC, thus the opposition and union busting. Unions are one of the biggest contributors to the DNC and the idea that if you want a job in a union shop you have to know somebody there goes against every principle America was founded on. Compulsory membership in unions defeats the very purpose they were formed for and has replaced the robber barons with the union barons. If you are part of a union it means you actually work in the trade you represent. Most union leadership never worked a day in their life and have no clue what the people they supposedly represent want, need or think. They nothing short of a parasitic corporation with all the nasty side effects of big biz but none of the redeeming qualities.



Economic systems should not and cannot effectively govern. A huge fallacy of both parties is the attempt to allow business to govern people.
libertarian
2013-04-12 05:56:31 UTC
Free market does not mean lack of laws regulating corruption and criminal activity. Free market does not mean that the public is responsible to bail out irresponsible risk takers.



If we actually did have pure capitalism backed up by a moral government to prosecute criminal activity you would be surprised how well it would work.



The problem we have is that almost everyone thinks it should be governments job to give them an advantage over their fellow citizen and that is what causes all the graft and corruption.
Michelle M
2013-04-13 20:50:59 UTC
The data on global warming has been manipulated. It's anything but "proven fact."



The free market provides the most equitable, most moral distribution of goods. Letting people keep as much as possible of what they create and earn is the fairest way and the freest way to organizae a society.



Taking from those who are successful just because they're successful in order to support the less successful deprives them of their incentive to become successful and deprives the successful of their incentive to keep doing what got them there. That lowers the standard of living for us all.
?
2013-04-12 05:51:49 UTC
All Capitalism means is: Your Property is yours only.



The Free Market only works when the government does not obstruct it.
Don M
2013-04-12 06:00:45 UTC
So you think profits are bad and man made global warming is real...



Could it be you also think professional wrestling is real and the moon landings were fake?
2013-04-12 05:44:22 UTC
Illusion.
2013-04-12 06:04:03 UTC
it is more of an illusion of freedoms

kind of like unlocking smart phones


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...