Question:
What is the secret about the USA's political stability?
João da Silva
2009-04-27 14:39:15 UTC
They have had the same constitution (OK, I know about the amendments) for more than two centuries; they've never had a dictatorship; there have never been any attempt of coup d'état; etc.

Some people say that the USA is a very well disguised military dictatorship. Others say it is the most perfect democracy in the world.

What are your views about it?
Nine answers:
2009-04-27 14:52:12 UTC
Freedom is a smoke screen. Our democracy is just very good at creatin the smoke screen to keep its power and avoid uprisings. If you are a dictator that is out there it is apparent to the people. But, if you have a system set up to where people believe they have a voice and a saying then they will continue living like sheeps. The governments owns us. Each year the first four months of our paychecks (if not more) go right to the government. We work for them and they collect our money. I would put it as noted "a well disguised dictatorship."
Brad
2009-04-27 15:02:49 UTC
The USA is a 1-party dictatorship in the guise of a multiparty Democracy. The Republicratic Party puts on show elections to bamboozle the public into supporting them (although occasionally, somebody who isn't a "centrist" gets nominated, in which case his own party revolts and he is defeated in a landslide; this happened in 1964 and 1972, but probably won't happen again, as the fates of Ron Paul, Dennis Kucinich, and Mike Gravel in the 2008 election show). In the past, both candidates ran on virtually identical policies. Nowadays, as Americans grew increasingly disgusted with big government and its wars in the 1960s and 1970s, the "Republican" pretends to be for limited government and the "Democrat" pretends to be for peace. However, once those pesky elections are over, the charade is up and both parties vote for bigger government and for wars and those opposed to expanding government are smeared as advocates of "polarization" and "divisiveness" and said to be opposed to "bipartisanship" (a more accurate thing to say is that "extremists" believe that the voters ought to be allowed to choose policies instead of merely pretending to choose).



It wasn't always this way. In the 19th century, America was a 2-party democracy and sometimes a 3-party or 4-party democracy (with the exception of a few years during the Monroe Administration). The parties stood for diametrically opposed ideas and Americans were much more enthusiastic in their support for parties. Each party published its own newspapers in each town, promoting the party line. This changed in 1896 when the Democratic Party was turned into a carbon copy of the Federalist/Whig/Republican Party following the Bryanite hijacking of that party. However, there would be an exodus of old Democrats to the Republican Party in the early years of the 20th century, which kept somewhat of a democratic political system in existence. From 1920-1928, America was ruled by Republicans who believed in the laissez-faire ideology of the 19th century Democrats, although Herbert Hoover, of the party's "left" wing became president in 1928 and began the New Deal. Many Republicans, however, opposed this and the Republicans remained somewhat of an opposition party until the early 1950s. At this time, CIA agent William F. Buckley Jr., the son of an "Old Right" Republican, created the "conservative" movement that destroyed the "Old Right," creating a permanent 1-party system.



Ironically, the Military-Industrial Complex's growth began around 1950. Today, it, along with Big Business, Big Labor, Big Religion, and others virtually control the nation's political system.



Personally, I don't think the charade will last much longer. Most Americans can now see the Republican Party for the fraud it is (including most who vote Republican; they don't like Republicans, they merely are against the Democrats). Soon, most Americans will see the Democratic Party for the fraud it is and then the game will be up for the elite.
Guy Fawkes
2009-04-27 14:49:53 UTC
Before this Post-Modern Era, we held onto the same libertarian values. We believed in limtied government, so no one would accept a dictator. We had no dictatorship because those arose in other countries as the result of the war of power and ambition that characterized europe, which America stayed out of and traded with everyone instead, even all parties in a major war. We stayed out of these conflicts and thus didn't suffer as these other countries did. because of this non-interventionist foreign policy, we had a strong and diverse economy fueled by industry and propelled by trade. A strong economy means no major calamities like rebellions and coups arise (mostly)



The most important thing to remember is 1/50th of our American Union of States equals the structure of the Federal Union. Therefore, each state can maintain order if the Federal Government is taken out of business, though a National currency makes this more difficult. This was how we maintained order during the War of 1812.
2009-04-27 14:44:28 UTC
There is no perfect government, there is no true singular form of government, we are a Republic as well as a Democracy. That being said the USA is the the finest form of government on planet earth. Military dictatorship, that doesn't even make sense, you have tanks patrolling your street? The US governmental form works.
?
2009-04-27 14:48:00 UTC
Freedom of speech. Hard to hide things in such a system.

It does mean we get nonsense like one of the answers above me talking about a dictatorship (hyperbole of the most contemptible sort, political bigotry), but it's the price we pay for the protections it gives us.

Most of the nonsense can't survive the deluge of truth that that freedom gives us.
2009-04-27 14:46:21 UTC
Our politicians are morons. The people realize how stupid they are before they can consolidate too much power and vote them out. Having freedoms of speech and the press help keep the government from monopolizing media and propagandizing the people too much.
2009-04-27 14:44:15 UTC
The Bill of Rights.
Metal Mike
2009-04-27 14:43:47 UTC
We go through fazes, for the last 8 years we have lived under a dictator, the people revolted in November and we voted in freedom.
2009-04-27 14:46:30 UTC
Citizen are too stupid to know what freedom is.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...