Question:
Does/ Can Power Corrupt People?
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:10:39 UTC
I need to write an essay, and i need three good points. Im a little bit stumped. If you could help me out, with three points, and maybe give further info on points, that would be great.

Here's what i have so far -

I believe it corrupts because of all the examples in our history and modern world.

Power does to your head.
25 answers:
Tazarian
2009-06-15 13:42:17 UTC
Power can corrupt someone, but it does not necessarily follow that it WILL corrupt someone.



(First point Personal Character)



As someone pointed out that absolute power, corrupts absolutely. I can think of one person, off the top of my head, that does not fall into that category. Queen Elizabeth of England. She is the most beloved and revered monarchs in English history. She was Queen in a time when that still meant something in the English government, and, by all accounts, her every decision was based on the benefit of the country and not of herself. In fact, she did not marry a man she reportedly loved because it could have damaged the english government. A little research in your local main library on monarchs should find several examples on both sides of the issue.



On the note of incomplete power, as is evidenced by America's Government... The President, nor any other office in the government has absolute power. I am sure that you have heard the term Checks and Balances. However, the minor power can go to some peoples heads. I believe this is more a question of individual character and morality than a blanket statement. If the character of the individual is such that they are focused more on what they personally can get out of any given situation, then it is more likely that they will be corrupted by any amount of power. However, if their character and moral beliefs are such that they focus more on what is best for others as a whole then they would be much less likely to succumb to degradation into corruption.



(Second Point - Public Opinion)



This is mainly a point that can be used in American Politics.



Although someone may be of a mind to sway toward corruptibility, if the majority of people will stand against any corruption, then the person will have no choice but to follow public opinion or risk losing their power. However, Just because someone does not follow public opinion does not mean they are corrupt. For example (and this is intentionally generic) , public opinion says that they want free use of sprokets, but it has been proven that sprokets are overly dangerous. An official that stands up against the use of sprokets is looking toward the benefit and safety of the whole (which kinda goes back to my first point but would make a good transition from one point to another).



(Third Point - Length of potential retention of power)



A dictator or monarch who will never (until death) be required to leave office is more likely to be corrupted than an official who takes office for only a small period of time. I.E. the fall into corruption, in most cases takes time, and the shorter the term of power, the less corrupt a person can become.



I understand that there will be exceptions to all of these items, but the topic of the essay is not a black and white, fact or fiction topic. There are grey areas involved that are based more on the person than on the power they represent.



I hope this helps, and if it does, I'd love to see how your paper turns out.
anonymous
2016-12-15 08:08:41 UTC
Power Corrupts Essay
Sfancik
2009-06-15 13:24:52 UTC
That's a good opening. Then I'd go like this...



For thousands of years and even before power has been a main factor in the corruption of people. This continues in modern times as well. Power makes a hard man humble, or so they say. Thus, power is truly dangerous because of the corruption that may occur.



Firstly of all, there is what power does to your head. Scientists and other historians have agreed, a human head cannot have that much power. Thus it has been said that power makes strange bedfellows.



Finally, in summation and with no false regrets, besides power we continue to wrestle with corruption and the awesome responsibility theretofore and inasmuch contained within...



....and blood feud.
?
2009-06-15 13:35:21 UTC
You can argue your essay through major points...



1. The one you already have, look at historical viewpoints



2. Examine the psychology behind the issue, look at studies that have put people in positions of authority/power and how they've abused it, there's one study that gives a very good example where two groups of students were set up as prisoners and prison guards; the students assigned as prison guards became obsessed with their roles and abused the prisoners; google it



3. Use our current country as an example, either the political structure or corporate model. Regarding politics, start out with our military expenditures, they're overly excessive to say the least. If you choose to go the corporate route, take a look at how common it is for businesses to "cut costs" through cheap/illegal/child labor. There are many routes you can choose, but you get the idea.
anonymous
2016-03-17 16:30:31 UTC
Yes ,without doubt , Just Look at the Vermin that Blair and his Low Life Cronies so called "New Labour" Corrupt , Corrupt , Corrupt
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:16:04 UTC
Of course it does. Most Democrats and Republicans are prime examples of this. Even though George Washington was a great man and some wanted him to be king, he became President instead because people were afraid power would corrupt him. The last example is Napoleon Bonaparte. He started out fighting for the people, but eventually when he got power, he let it go to his head and conquered numerous countries.
ZxssxZ
2009-06-15 13:17:35 UTC
I believe in the other way, Corrupt people mis utilize power. Having power to do some things doesn't make anyone corrupt. There may be a case when they have taken the bad decision but i can't say them corrupt.
mom
2009-06-15 13:32:54 UTC
A lot of people who are in power are not corrupt. Truth is, power itself should not corrupt. The problem with power is that some people who have it let it go to their head and get that feeling of 'Holier Than Thou' when it comes to using that power and thus become corrupt.
Davey
2009-06-15 13:13:46 UTC
Absolute Power, Corrupts Absolutely!
L1t1g8r
2009-06-17 13:52:44 UTC
Well I think your question is somewhat vague. What KIND of can power are you talking about. I mean a can of beer may give a guy courage, but not much power. A can of whoopa**, well if it is opened in your direction, then you could say that can power is certainly corrupting.
G S
2009-06-15 13:18:38 UTC
Well a good example is that of the Nazis, Hitler got way to much power and killed 11 million people in concentration camps. You could also use an example of maybe a bully from your younger years, or someone "popular." They could get a lot of power from popularity, it could get to there head and make fun of people, making peoples life miserable.
Doctor Insanity
2009-06-15 13:30:59 UTC
Power can corrupt anyone. for someone to have so much power there comes great responsibility and those who use that power with great responsibility dose great things. power is also like poison as well as a treasure. you can do so much with that power and you can easily abuse your privileges in the process. through out history there were leaders who used that power wisely and leaders who manipulated others for their own selfish needs. how you use that power is up to you. you can use that great power for the greater good or you can use it for your own personal wants and needs, but be warned. with great power comes great responsibility and great consciences.
MikeGolf
2009-06-15 13:16:55 UTC
Power that is not counterbalanced by accountibility does tend to corrupt.



One of the biggest issues that power creates is that people with power somethines think that they are 'above' the rules everybody else has to follow.



Bill Clinton is an example here. He honestly did not believe that he should have been held to the same standard as everybody else during the Monica Lewinsky affair.
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:24:49 UTC
power, corrupts



absolute power, corrupts absolutely



if you have the time read a book called "Animal Farm" its kinda long but very good!



it formats russia as a farm, when it became soviet as a dictator takes over the farm, it shows what power does to you. its really good! :)
45 auto
2009-06-15 14:38:18 UTC
Follow the Gov in the USA. There will be enough to write a full novel.
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:18:10 UTC
Power corrupts because you are no longer held responsible for your actions.
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:16:07 UTC
Good people are changed by Power
My two cents
2009-06-15 13:16:30 UTC
power corrupts those in higher places because they don't want to look down on others and remember they were once there. nor help them up off there feet because they are scared of falling.



it also makes people currupt by them having less to do and no longer wanting to get there hands dirty in work situations.
Ninja Joe
2009-06-15 13:20:15 UTC
Yes, thats why the government should have no power.
In Defense of ☭Marxism
2009-06-15 13:14:18 UTC
Watch the movie Dark Knight, then you know.
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:17:01 UTC
Power cannot corrupt Barack Obama.



It is impossible to corrupt someone who was already corrupt.
imzadi192000
2009-06-15 13:15:32 UTC
As long as there is evil still in existence, yes.
in vino veritas
2009-06-15 13:15:15 UTC
Possibly...



...but money - and the lust for it - corrupts absolutely.
anonymous
2009-06-15 13:13:50 UTC
yes!
Aj G
2009-06-15 13:15:32 UTC
no


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...